Slope.
Dead-flat and shallow flat roofs belong to membrane systems. Anything with real pitch is a candidate for metal.
Standing seam and flat metal roofing, repairs and replacement for commercial and industrial buildings.
Standing seam is a panel system where adjacent panels are joined by a raised, mechanically seamed or snap-locked vertical rib that sits above the water line. Fasteners are concealed in clips under the seam, so nothing penetrates the water plane in the field of the roof. Those clips allow the panel to expand and contract along its length, which matters in a climate that swings across a wide temperature range between a January night and a July afternoon.
The alternative, exposed-fastener profiles, screws through the face of the panel into the structure. It is quicker and cheaper to install and remains common on agricultural and utility buildings, but every screw is a penetration with a gasket, and those gaskets are what fail. A large share of metal roof leaks we attend on exposed-fastener roofs are simply hundreds of tired washers and elongated screw holes.
On commercial buildings we specify concealed-fastener standing seam wherever the slope, the budget and the structure allow it, and detail the eaves, ridges, valleys, hips, wall abutments and penetrations in matching metal rather than sealant.
Yes, within limits, and the limit is slope. Every metal panel profile has a minimum slope below which it should not be used, because the seam relies on water moving off the roof rather than sitting on it. Below that threshold, a mechanically seamed panel with a sealant in the seam is required, and below that again, a membrane system is the correct answer.
flat metal is common on older industrial buildings across the GTA, often over a purlin structure with no deck. Typical issues are seam capillary action and back-up at the eave, thermal movement tearing at fixed points, corrosion at the laps and at cut edges, condensation on the underside where there is no vapour control, and ice damming at gutters and eaves during a Toronto thaw. Retrofitting insulation and a vapour barrier to an uninsulated metal roof is a design exercise, not a patch.
Where a flat metal roof is failing across the field, two paths are common: a full metal re-roof, or a retrofit assembly with insulation and a single-ply or SBS membrane installed over the existing panels. We assess the structure, the corrosion and the drainage before recommending either. See flat roof replacement for the membrane route and industrial roofing for large-span buildings.

Commercial roof at scale
They are not competitors so much as answers to different questions.
Dead-flat and shallow flat roofs belong to membrane systems. Anything with real pitch is a candidate for metal.
Dozens of units, curbs and pipes are far easier to flash into a membrane. A metal roof with many penetrations loses much of its advantage.
Membrane assemblies with a cover board and walkway pads take service traffic better. Metal panels dent and the finish scars.
Standing seam is a visible architectural element on street-facing elevations, mansards and canopies, and pairs with the metal cladding described on roof flashing and siding.
The full membrane comparison is on flat roof types.
On many GTA buildings the answer is both. A sloped street elevation or a mansard in standing seam, and a flat membrane behind it over the main structure, is a common arrangement, and the junction between the two is where the detailing has to be right.
Our metal work spans repair, component replacement and full re-roofing.
Metal work sits alongside our flat services on commercial roofing, and completed work is shown in the gallery.
Exposed-fastener panels rely on a rubber washer under each screw head. Washers harden and crack with ultraviolet exposure and temperature cycling, and repeated thermal movement gradually elongates the hole so the screw no longer seats. The remedy is a fastener replacement programme with oversized screws and new washers, not a bead of sealant over each head.
Sometimes, using a sub-purlin or hat-channel retrofit framing system over the old panels. It avoids tear-off and keeps the building closed in, and it creates a cavity that can take insulation. It depends on the condition and capacity of the existing structure, so the added load is confirmed before anything is specified.
Far less than people expect on a commercial building. Noise comes from panels installed over open framing with nothing behind them. Over a deck with insulation and underlayment, or in a retrofit assembly with a filled cavity, rain noise is not usually a complaint we hear from occupants.
Warm humid interior air reaching the cold underside of the panel, where it condenses and drips. It is very common in uninsulated or poorly vapour-controlled industrial buildings and is often mistaken for a leak. The clue is that it appears on cold clear days rather than during rain. The fix is thermal and vapour control, not sealant.
No. NorthCan Roofing works on commercial and industrial buildings only. Our metal work covers commercial standing seam, flat industrial metal, cladding and associated flashing and trim.